shawna@thebuyerinsider.com651-470-0066Book a Call/Zoom
← All Episodes
Episode 41Solo Episode

How to Know If Your Marketing Is Actually Working

with Shawna Suckow

· 19 minutes

Watch Episode 41

Watch on YouTube · Apple Podcasts · Spotify

A post gets 3,000 likes. An email gets two inquiries and one sale. One of those looks better on a dashboard, and the other helps cover payroll.

In this episode of Underestimated, Shawna Suckow shares five ways to find out which marketing deserves more of your time and money. You’ll learn to give each activity a job, measure what it accomplishes, ask customers what influenced them, and decide what to keep, improve, or stop.

What You Will Learn

  • Give every email, post, or ad a purpose in your Marketing Mosaic.
  • Choose a metric that matches the goal and use trackable links, landing pages, or simple tests.
  • Ask customers how they found you and what helped them decide to buy.
  • Build a scorecard around the customer actions, time, and spending that matter to your business.
  • Look for a pattern before deciding what to keep, improve, or stop.

Episode Resources

Marketing Measurement Scorecard

Choose one activity to evaluate this week and give it a clear purpose. Use these prompts to record the results and decide when you’ll review them.

  1. Activity and purpose: What are you testing, and which customer action should it support?
  2. Metric: Identify up to three things you’ll measure.
  3. Cost and time: Record the money and hours invested.
  4. Test period: Track when and how often you ran it, which actions it produced, and any patterns or outside factors.
  5. Decision: Choose what to keep, improve, or stop, and set the next review date.

Episode Chapters

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if my small-business marketing is working?

Give each activity a purpose and track the customer action it is meant to support. For an email designed to generate sales, count inquiries and conversions alongside the time and money you spent.

When are likes and comments worth tracking?

Likes, comments, saves, and clicks can indicate whether educational content is reaching and engaging people. When a campaign is designed to generate sales, track outcomes such as appointments, orders, and revenue.

What should I ask customers to find out what marketing worked?

Ask how they heard about you and what helped them decide to buy. Ask close to the purchase so the details are fresh.

How long should I test a marketing tactic?

Give it enough repetitions to see a pattern and allow for your buying cycle, seasonality, and timing. Shawna uses 90 days as a rule of thumb for a new social campaign and adjusts it to the business.

Full Transcript

Read the full Episode 41 transcript

How do you know if your marketing is working to bring new customers to your small business? Well, if you are doing all the things like sending out the emails, and posting on all the social channels, and doing all the mailers and advertisements, and you're just not seeing the results, how do you know what's not working, especially if you don't have a huge marketing firm behind you doing all of the analysis in the background and all the metrics and so forth. Well, if you're struggling with this, this episode is for you, and by the end of this rapid fire episode, you're gonna know 5 things you can do to help you figure out what's working and what isn't.

So let's dive in. Depending on what you're selling, a bunch of likes might not translate to a bunch of new customers. In fact, the higher the ticket item that you sell Let's say that you sell a service, and that service is $1,000, and you do a post on something, and it gets you 300 or 3,000 likes, doesn't matter, and not a single phone call. Those likes don't mean anything. But if you try something else, maybe you send out an email and it gets 2 inquiries, and one of those converts, then that email that had a much more limited reach actually did a better job for you.

So if you post something and it gets you 300 likes, it's not necessarily gonna pay your electrical bill or cover payroll for the month. So let's figure out what does, and how do we measure it? Let's start with figuring out what the purpose is of every one of your marketing activities. A post does not always have to be a pitch with an end result, a buy now. In fact, those types of posts rarely work in a vacuum.

They rarely work on their own. I talk about the marketing mosaic, and today customers may need more than one reason to trust your company. Every marketing message, every post on social, it has to have a purpose. So decide what that purpose is, and there are several different types of purposes. It can be a pitch, which I always say you should do on a limited basis.

You should spend more time building trust and building your reputation and your likability than pitching because if you are pitching all the time, you are largely being ignored, unless it is something where you absolutely have the lowest price. And do you wanna compete just on price? If the answer is yes, you keep doing you, boo. But if you don't wanna compete on price, let's work on pitching not quite as often and focus on the other pieces of the mosaic. So if you think of marketing, your whole brand, the whole marketing message that you wanna deliver, which is, "Please notice us, please trust us, and please remember us so that when you decide you wanna move forward, you think of nobody else but us, and there is nobody else you'd rather buy from but us.

"So that's the mosaic we're trying to build, and every post that you do, every email that you send, ad that you build, each one of those is just one tile in that mosaic. And your mosaic keeps growing and growing as your company grows and as your company becomes older and more experienced and has more of a customer base. So your marketing mosaic is never finished. You never solve the marketing equation and just do that forever. No.

This is evolving just like you are, just like your business is. And so what we wanna do is figure out what is the purpose of each tile. And so that means, okay, is this post that I'm gonna do every Monday Maybe I'm gonna do a post that gives a tip about something. Okay? The purpose of that post is educating your customers, and in doing so, the secondary purpose is building trust and standing out, building likability.

And maybe another thing that you do is an email that goes out once a month that's more of a newsletter, but it also tells stories about your customers and shares photos of your actual employees doing things in the community. That's all about building goodwill. It's also got a little bit of education, and also there's probably a little bit of a pitch. So it's okay to have one marketing piece do double or triple duty, but just decide that upfront because then you know what to measure and how to move forward with that. So an educational piece doesn't have to be measured in closed business.

It can be measured in engagement. That one is okay, like if people comment on it or the number of likes, that sort of thing. That can be measured in engagement because its job was not to close deals. Of course, we want every thing we put out to lead to closed deals. But the purpose of that one thing in your whole mosaic was to educate.

That's it. Now let's look at something else like a podcast. So this podcast, I rarely, if ever, pitch anything on my podcast. I may say, "Read the blog," or, "Go to my marketing vault where there are all these free resources. "So for that, I am doing this podcast to build awareness, to build trust, to share education, to share resources so that when it comes time for you to recommend a speaker if you're on the committee of a chamber or for you to hire somebody to do a marketing assessment for your small business, you'll think of me, and you'll already believe that I know what I'm talking about.

Every episode of my podcast has to lead to one speaking engagement where I'm being hired. That is not the purpose of this podcast at all. That would be great if it happened, but again, not the purpose. If it was, then I would spend time on every podcast going, "Hire me, hire me. "And what would you do?

You would tune out. Tune out. So you also have to align tile in your mosaic with the mission, and again, can't always be pitching. We're talking about standing out from your competitors, and they are likely always pitching, and building that trust which your competitors struggle with. Every business struggles with it.

So if you are the one that's using microstories in your marketing, and you're being helpful, and you have that FAQ on your website, and you're legitimately sharing resources and knowledge and doing things like that, then you're building trust, and then being memorable. Those are also where stories come in, because as I've said just in my last episode of the podcast, stories are 22 times more memorable than facts or features. So these are all the types of things, like is this, is this particular post, or is this page on my website, is this advertisement, is this newsletter, what is the mission of it? And that will lead you to how you can measure whether it did its job or not.

Okay, now that we've talked about figuring out what the mission, what the purpose of every post, every tile in your mosaic is, now let's talk about how do we measure the impact that it's having? Well, I gave one example about the number of clicks, the number of likes, the number of comments. If you include a link, like say you're talking about here are 3 things you can do to keep your pipes from bursting in the cold Minnesota winter, and say that that's a video on You Tube, and at the end or in the show notes you say, "Here is a checklist," or, "Here is a page where you can download this thing or get a realistic look at how likely your pipes are to burst based on how old they are, based on where you're located, et cetera," and that resides on a web page, and you're driving traffic to that web page based on that video, something you say in the video, something that appears on the screen, then that's easily measured.

You can measure the views of that video, the likes, the comments on the video, but you can also measure the number of visits to that page. And especially if that page is a hidden page that nobody else can access but the people who have the link, this is a fantastic way to measure whether it was effective or not. So not every business has the time to do that, and if you don't, don't worry about it. There are things like Google Analytics that will help you measure things, and you don't have to set up separate web pages to test every single thing that you do. God forbid, you wouldn't have time to sleep.

So this is about for those big things, like if you're doing a new rollout and you're testing to see what you want to invest your money in, and you don't have unlimited funds, then something like this may be worth it. You do an A/B test. Version A is the You Tube video that says this. Version B can be another You Tube or it can be an email, and you measure which one is most effective, and then throw your money behind that. Because if you're a small business, you don't have money to spread thin amongst all these things, because money spread thin typically doesn't work as well as money that's focused behind something you have already proven is going to work for you.

So use this as you're able, and put the time and effort behind the things that truly matter, don't worry about every single post being measured. The next way to know if your marketing is working is by asking customers a couple questions. Once they have converted and they've bought from you, and let's say you send out a survey, or they're right in front of you and they're at that cash register, or however you connect with your customers, ask them a couple questions. Number one: How did you hear about us? It's a great question to ask.

And if you do a survey, I have written a blog on how to do surveys that work that I will link to in the show notes down below, because boring surveys rarely get answered unless that person is very hot or very cold on your business. So they loved their experience, and they're gonna take the time out of their day to answer your survey, or they hated their interaction with your business, and they're gonna leave you this scathing review on your survey. So surveys done the boring way, eh, not very effective. They're great for collecting information as an afterthought, and they certainly don't do any harm. They're gonna point out, point out your blind spots, and they're gonna give you pats on the back where you need them, but read that blog to figure out how to really do a strong survey.

But in this example, if you're asking, "How did you hear about us? "fabulous. And you can gather that intel over time and see patterns as to what's working and what's not. But if you only send the survey out to customers that buy online, for example, and you don't do any type of survey with customers who buy in store, then the results are gonna be skewed. So just make sure that you acknowledge that when you're getting those results.

Okay, what did we leave out, or what did we overlook, or how can these results be skewed, and how can we not just look at these through rose-colored glasses? Speaking of which, I'm not wearing my rose-colored glasses. No wonder I'm having trouble seeing. Oh my gosh, there you go. I can see.

So the second question is, what helped you decide to buy today? What was that thing that made you decide to come into the store today, or why did you decide to call us? What made you decide to book the appointment? And this is something that if somebody has taken action to do business with you, they're more than likely gonna answer this, especially the sooner it's asked. If you got them on the phone, if you've got them in front of you, great.

Or if you send out a survey that's actually built around getting good results for you, then those results are going to work for you and give you the answers that you need. And next to last, not in order of importance by any means, but I've got 2 more tips, and this is the next to the last one. So build a scorecard that keeps track of the information you really need and doesn't waste your time with information that doesn't really matter to you. And so what are you going to track that matters? Well, certainly monthly spending toward different types of marketing, that's worth tracking.

Time, if you're able to track the amount of time that you or an employee or an intern spent on this, that's also perhaps worth tracking, and these are all up to you. There's no hard and fast rules as to what should or should not be tracked. It's all a matter of what gets measured gets done, and what gets done well will show up in the measurements. I just made that up. That's kinda clever.

What about new customers? The amount of new customers that you booked this month as opposed to this time last year or this month compared to last month when most things are remaining equal. It can also be measuring referrals. It can be measuring repeat purchases, any of those things. And so measuring the things that matter and forgetting the ones that don't, because ain't nobody got time to measure 72 different things and weed through all those variables, so focus in on what's truly gonna be helpful for you.

And my last tip for figuring out if your marketing is working for you as hard as it could is decide what to keep doing, what to keep doing with improvements, and what to stop because it just wasn't worth the time, the money, the results that it got. So you may decide, okay, these are the things I'm gonna keep because they're producing fantastic results, or they're producing nice results for the money that I spent. So these things are worth it, and these things would be worth it if I could cut down on the amount of time that this takes or cut down on the amount of money. Like social media advertising is a big one. In social media advertising, you can throw a lot of money at it and not have results but still get good information back.

You can spend hundreds of dollars on figuring out what doesn't work, or you can do $100 and figure out what doesn't work and then improve on the things that do and do more of those things. So that's $100 well spent, and it's definitely worth keeping that social media advertising if it's working for you or if you believe it could with tweaks, rather than just saying, "Well, that was a huge waste of time," and just throwing it out altogether. So if something seems promising and it just takes a little tweak here or there, before you throw it out, go ahead and improve it. So what do you keep going the way it is, what do you keep but improve, and what do you stop doing altogether?

And the stop doing altogether, those really can only be decided based on the impact that they're having and the things that you're measuring. Are they contributing to the bottom line? Great. So inexpensive activities can still take up way too much time, and there are also things, patterns that will emerge when you start to measure what matters to you and not measure what doesn't matter to you, and those patterns are gonna help you decide what's working. Is it cyclical?

Is it seasonal? Did I give it enough time for it to be a fair measurement? If you try one thing one time on one random Tuesday and it didn't work that one time, that could be a number of factors, so you also have to give it enough time. And one of the things that I say with any new social media campaign is if you are trying something brand-new, like say you've rebranded or you're rolling out a new initiative or a new service, the rule of thumb for me is generally give it 90 days before you just completely ditch it. Now, I said rule of thumb for me because your buying cycle may be years or your buying cycle may be days, and 90 days may be too long or too short for your needs.

But you've gotta give it more than just one shot. And so aggregate your results and take a look at those from a macro perspective, not just a micro perspective, and these will help you decide. All of these things will help you decide whether each thing that you're doing is working or not. Should you keep it as is? Should you keep it but improve it?

Or should you stop doing it altogether? So your challenge for this episode is choose one thing. Choose one format. Are you going to choose one platform, let's say? Say it's LinkedIn, and you're going to measure a series of posts on LinkedIn whose job it is to educate, and you're gonna measure those not just one Wednesday, but you're gonna measure them over a series of Wednesdays.

Or you're gonna measure them on different days of the week or different times and figure out what has the best impact, and the impact is what you decided it. Is it the number of likes? Is it the number of calls? Is it the number of DMs that you get? Is it the number of comments?

What is it that you're measuring? And give it enough time to decide whether it is going to work or not, and then that one thing in a month or however many number of repetitions make sense for your business, you're gonna know, is it worth continuing? And so measure again the things that, that matter to you and repeat them enough to get enough of a base to make the decision wisely, and end the review with the ultimate decision. As I said, you gonna keep it, you gonna keep it with improvements, or you gonna just ditch it? And again, don't just ditch it after one try.

So in closing, focus on one thing, one tile, one form of marketing over the next period, whether that's a month for you, depending on your buying cycle, whether it's 90 days, and really give it a fair shake so that it is measurable. You know, sometimes in small businesses we throw spaghetti against the wall to see if it sticks. Well, we can do better, and time permitting, money permitting, here's something that you can try. So thank you so much for tuning in. This has been another episode of Underestimated, and one thing that you can do for me is to please forward this to somebody who is struggling to find out if their marketing is making a difference or not.

Appreciate you. Thanks. See you next time.