shawna@thebuyerinsider.com651-470-0066Book a Call/Zoom
← All Episodes
Episode 40Solo Episode

The Marketing Tactics That Make Customers Distrust You

with Shawna Suckow

· 17 minutes

Watch Episode 40

Watch on YouTube · Apple Podcasts · Spotify

Fake deadlines. Fake handwriting. “Second request” envelopes designed to look official. Customers have seen the tricks, and they are not nearly as gullible as some marketers seem to think.

In this episode of Underestimated, I call out the scammy tactics that make customers distrust a business before they even consider the offer. I also explain how to use real urgency, honest scarcity, customer stories, and FOMO without torching the trust you worked so hard to earn.

You will learn how to make a deadline believable, explain real capacity limits, respond to “I’ll think about it,” and build trust before you ask someone to act.

What You Will Learn

  • Why fake urgency and moving deadlines train customers not to believe you.
  • How to explain a real deadline, seasonal limit, or capacity constraint.
  • Why “I’ll think about it” may call for more information or trust, not more pressure.
  • How to build trust before introducing a countdown or limited-time offer.
  • How real customer stories create believable FOMO without the ick.

Episode Resources

Trust First Urgency Checklist

Before you add a deadline, countdown, scarcity claim, or limited-time offer, answer these questions:

  1. Is the deadline or limit real? If you are not prepared to keep it, remove it.
  2. Why does it exist? Explain the actual inventory, season, schedule, production, or capacity constraint.
  3. What changes afterward? Tell customers what will no longer be available.
  4. Have you built trust first? Add a sample, demonstration, FAQ, customer story, or specific proof before applying pressure.
  5. What information is still missing? Make it easier for the customer to decide or discuss the purchase with someone else.
  6. Does it sound honest out loud? If the wording feels manipulative face-to-face, rewrite it.

Keep Going

Frequently Asked Questions

How can a small business create urgency without looking scammy?

Use a real deadline or capacity limit, explain why it exists, and keep it. Customers should understand what changes after the deadline and why you cannot simply move it.

Why do moving deadlines hurt customer trust?

A repeatedly extended deadline teaches customers that the original claim was not real. They are less likely to believe the next deadline or the offer behind it.

What does “I’ll think about it” mean in sales?

The customer may need more information, another decision-maker, or more trust. More pressure may make the concern worse; useful proof and a clearer next step can reduce uncertainty.

Can a countdown timer ever work without hurting trust?

Yes, when trust and value have already been established and the timer reflects a real deadline. Explain what expires and why.

Full Transcript

Read the full Episode 40 transcript

0:00–1:26

You're listening to Underestimated, the podcast that helps overwhelmed small business owners turn their size into their unfair advantage So they can grow without burning out. Now, here's your host, Shawna Suckow. As consumers, we've all seen these ads that push scarcity or urgency.

There's a time limit or a sense of missing out. But as small business owners, are these things that we should adapt into our own marketing? Well, if you are curious about this, or if you've tried it and it didn't really work for you, then give this episode a listen. So when we talk about scarcity and urgency and FOMO, these are three very legitimate tools that marketers can use when they're trying to get the customer to move toward a desired action, which is usually take the next step or buy the thing, whatever it is.

But these can be misused and today consumers, all of us, we are so much more distrustful of businesses than we were five years ago, ten years ago. And so trust is so valuable. We cannot afford to squander it.

And even the smallest mistake can cost you trust forever. And those customers, once they distrust you, may as well move on because it is so much harder to re-earn that trust than to just start over with somebody new. So let's not lose their trust to begin with.

1:26–2:08

I'm going to call out a few businesses here that are using really shady marketing tactics that just immediately cause distrust. And if one of these big businesses happens to see it, great. I hope you do.

And I hope you stop the scammy marketing. And if they don't see it, well, more power to you because as a small business, you can compete better with these guys who are losing trust left and right and don't even realize it because they're just not paying attention to how their customers have evolved over the past five to ten years. OK, the first example is playing on a sense of urgency, but it's really ironic what they're selling.

2:08–2:22

And so the first order of shame goes out to AAA and their life insurance company. Life insurance has been marketed in very scammy ways for a long time. And you think they would have changed this by now.

2:22–2:42

They keep doing it because in some instances it works for them, maybe on older people, older boomers and so forth who aren't as savvy as the majority of consumers today. So they are fighting a losing battle because they have not adapted. So let me show you this.

2:42–2:54

If you are just listening to this, I'll describe it to you. This is the second request. And when you see it through the envelope, it looks like a certificate and it says state of Minnesota on it because that's where I live and it's very glossy.

2:55–3:11

And when you open it up, it says second request proof of eligibility. And your name here is eligible for term life insurance at group rates available only to AAA members and their spouses. The rates are the lowest they've been since 2018 blah, blah, blah.

3:11–3:35

So this fake sense of urgency and this second request BS and all of this horrible marketing is causing them to lose trust. And the sense of urgency, by the way, when you're selling life insurance means you think that person is about to die. I mean, so AAA shame on you.

3:36–3:56

And then one other thing they do is when you open it up further and you see the letter that they've written, they try this fake handwriting font and they put it in blue. So it looks like blue ink and they've written in the margins say even more if you don't use nicotine. Did you forget to reply? OK, so also shaming your customer, your potential customer for forgetting to reply.

3:57–4:41

This is just all around that. So how can you create a sense of urgency that doesn't completely flop like this? Well, first of all, on your website or in your marketing established that the process takes time, whatever amount of time that is, whether it's a matter of hours or whether it's a matter of days, weeks. If you are in home construction and you are super busy during the summer months, then there is a real sense of urgency and you just convey that in an honest, upfront, forthright way by telling them what your process is and maybe even offering some of discount or bonus add on if they take the action early so that they get logged in before your busy season.

4:42–4:57

And so explaining that on your website, explaining it in your marketing and don't just say act now. Sale ending soon because here's another one that gets the shame score. Renewal by Andersen.

4:57–5:20

I get these every week in those mailers that come with a lot of called suburban living where I live and it comes with a lot of coupons from various businesses, mostly homeowner related. Well, this one is it's National Window Replacement Month. I think every month happens to be National Window Replacement Month with these guys.

5:21–6:10

And then they are saying that basically act now and they're also using the scammy handwriting and they're also using the scammy fake highlighting like they wrote this just for me. They've handwritten and then highlighted all this just for me when we all know that they've mass produced this and this has a distinct look to it now that whenever I see it, I immediately distrust it. And so I will not be buying anything from Renewal by Andersen.

They have lost my trust permanently. I don't know that there is a good enough deal that they could leverage that would get me to buy from them because I wouldn't trust the deal. And they're not going to get my attention anymore unless I'm using it to shame them in a podcast like this.

6:11–6:29

And by the way, these are my opinions only. So, Renewal by Andersen, this is my opinion. Don't sue me.

So don't don't use these tactics with the fake sense of urgency. And then here is another one. Leaf filter gutter replacement, gutter protection, excuse me.

6:29–6:52

And they, well, first of all, this this whole print ad is just rife with things that they're doing incorrectly. So if you are a smaller company, you can compete against LeafFilter by just not doing half of these things. They are often offering they're doing that the fake handwriting font, they're doing the fake highlighting.

6:53–7:28

They're saying they're using things that every single company in home services offer, like free estimate today and zero this and zero that and 25% off in a senior and military discount and call or scan before October 31st for your free gutter inspection. Oh, no, I missed that deadline. What shall I do? Well, guess what? Every time I get one of these, that deadline has moved a little further and nothing is real.

7:29–7:41

No, deadline is real. No sense of urgency is real. And I will say as a caveat, none of these things, like if you're offering a discount or a senior or military or first responder discount, fantastic.

7:42–8:07

Just say it in a way that your competitors aren't saying and make it meaningful. Tell a story. Why do you offer that? Was somebody involved in a terrible accident and first responders saved their life or was your grandfather in the military? Were you in the military? Look back at my other podcasts and blogs where I talk about storytelling, especially micro stories.

8:07–8:27

That's a whole other episode that I don't get into beyond what I've already done, but another fake sense of urgency. So what can you do? As I've said, tell a real story. When you offer a special deal, make sure that it really does expire and don't say discount extended one more week.

8:28–8:41

We have been trained to expect that. And so we don't believe that the first deadline is always real. So you're going to have to work extra hard to convey, yes, this deadline is real.

8:42–8:51

And unlike those other companies where the deadline keeps moving and never seems to ever happen, our deadline is real. And here's why. That's all you have to do.

8:51–9:32

And then you can absolutely use urgency. Are you about to run out of something? Is the seasonal thing going to not be available in another week? Is there, is it weather related? Is it whatever related then convey that to them and just tell them in an honest, straightforward way without all the fake handwriting and highlighting and all of the fake urgency. Before I continue, let me just say this about urgency that customers very often use the excuse that I'll think about it and I'll think about it means I don't trust the offer or I don't trust your company or I need more information.

9:33–9:49

Or have to talk it over with somebody. I know a lot of sales training says that you just need to push harder. What that means is that they really do have to talk about it with somebody else because they're not the sole decision maker or they don't trust your company or they need more information.

9:49–10:03

They want to do it in the background without you being involved. So there are some things that you can do to circumvent this and to help nudge them along. I just actually took advantage of it just yesterday.

10:04–10:24

It was an offer to record and produce and do all the things to make sure that my audio book gets launched, which is something I've been putting off for a year. I released my latest book, Small Is Your Superpower, a year ago and I did the Kindle version. I just never got around to doing the audio version because I saw it as this big endeavor.

10:24–10:38

Well, this company came along and they said, here's what we can do. And would you mind if we shared a free sample? And I was like, actually, that sounds like something I am interested in. So they sent a free sample and they said, here's what we've created for you.

10:38–10:54

And it was legit customized to me. It was a sample of the first chapter of my book and I was very impressed and they did have a timer clicking down. I don't like particularly the 24 hour or three day or whatever timer clicking down.

10:54–11:08

It does instill a sense of urgency and it did work on me, but only because they built trust with me first. If they would have led with, hey, for the next 24 hours, I only get your audio book produced. I would have never opened the email.

11:08–11:19

I never would have responded to the guy. So he established trust first. And so think about that as a small business before you use any of these as leverage.

11:19–11:39

Make sure that trust is already baked in to what you're talking about or the micro stories. Micro stories are great at building trust, 22 times more memorable facts and features. So your stories matter and they are important to tie in when you are stating that there's urgency or scarcity.

11:41–12:09

And then lastly, when we talk about FOMO, yes, fear of missing out is is real. It's legit and we can do this by leveraging testimonials of other customers and also those real deadlines and that real scarcity. But hearing the scarcity, the FOMO, the sense of urgency through the voice of a customer who doesn't have any skin in the game and who says, hey, I'm not getting paid to say this.

12:09–12:25

I'm not getting any kickback or anything like that. I just really want to rave about this company. So if you have people offering to do that or say yes, when you ask, make sure that they they say something like that, if they're willing, upfront that they aren't a paid promoter.

12:26–12:40

They are a real customer. Think about drug advertisements where in the bottom and really small print, it says these are paid actors. Do you trust the drug advertiser a little less? Yes.

12:41–13:04

So real people giving a real sense of FOMO and conveying with you the scarcity and the urgency is fantastic if you can make that happen. Let me end with a couple of examples for urgency. How about you're producing an event registration closes on Friday because we have to order materials.

13:04–13:40

We have to confirm our our count for food and beverage and we absolutely can't accept late registrations. Something like that is real, is going to work more than, hey, registration closes on Friday and then guess what? Registration is extended another week. What does that tell you when they've extended registration another week? It tells you that the event didn't get all the registrations that they were hoping for and that it kind of instills a little distrust that the event is worthwhile it also builds distrust that the deadline is never the deadline with you.

13:41–13:57

And sadly, as I said earlier, so many companies have abused the fake urgency that we have to work extra hard now to really just confirm and convey and prove that the deadline is the deadline. And actually saying that is one way you can do it. Just actually say it.

13:58–14:14

Hey, guys, I know a lot of other companies use this as leverage, but we mean it. This deadline is firm and we literally can't help you if you register late or if you don't get the same time scarcity. This is an example of this is here's one that I don't like.

14:15–14:26

I'm opening up three slots for my new coaching business and no, you're not. No, you're not. You will take everybody that is willing to pay you if you're a new coaching business.

14:27–14:39

So what you can say is, hey, I am only doing this three hours a week. I have one hour a week filled. I have two more slots and I will let you know when those are filled.

14:39–14:58

And this will not open again until this three month period is up because I work in three month chunks. So really explaining why or having an FAQ on your website that tells them why. These are the things that matter when we're using these as leverage and then fear of missing out.

14:58–15:10

Say that you are doing a workshop. Well, the live demonstration or the interview with the expert, anything like that is only available live. So you have to be there.

15:11–15:20

So you have to be there. It's not going to be available in a recording. There is not going to be a recording or the recording won't have these assets included.

15:21–16:04

So make sure that you convey what and why so that they understand what they're missing out on if they don't take the next step in time. So these are some really simple ways that you can maintain trust or build trust with somebody brand new without without resorting to these scammy tactics that we see all the time. And I bet you the next time you get one of these value packs or suburban living magazines with all the the home related coupons and deals inside, you will look at that differently next time because of these seeds that I've planted in your head.

16:04–16:15

So now as a consumer, you're going to distrust companies a little bit more when you see these things. So as a business owner, don't do these. Don't make the mistake of doing these yourself.

16:16–16:20

Thanks for listening. This has been another episode of Underestimated. We will see you next time.

16:21–16:26

Thanks for listening to Underestimated hosted by Shawna Suckow. To connect with Shauna, go to thebuyerinsider.com.